Penguin, Overdrive, and Amazon: Kindle Library Lending Gets Complicated

Kindle owners found themselves targeted recently in a fairly unpleasant way.  Penguin USA, one of the largest publishers in the world, decided that it would be a smart business move to pull their entire collection of publications from libraries across the country for Kindle owners.  Everybody else, including owners of competing eReaders like the Barnes & Noble Nook Simple Touch, could still get these books.  Now, while things have been temporarily dealt with since then – Penguin has temporarily stopped singling out the Kindle users entirely – new Penguin books will not be made available anymore and there is reason to believe that the event will recur unless Penguin and OverDrive (the service providing eBook lending services for most libraries these days) are able to work out a deal by the end of the year.

Neither Penguin nor OverDrive has said anything about the exact details of Penguin’s problems.  OverDrive was simply sent word to disable the “Get for Kindle” functionality for all Penguin eBooks immediately.  There was not even a warning sent to the affected libraries before the change took effect, which led to a great deal of ill will.  These libraries purchase each copy of the eBooks they rent out and as such were left sitting on the results of essentially wasted money that could not be lent out despite Kindle-owning customer demand.  The expected outcry for massive refunds, which would certainly have garnered a great deal of public sympathy, might well explain Penguin’s temporary capitulation.

Many have believably argued that this is a direct response to the Kindle Owners’ Lending Library that Amazon launched recently for their Prime members.  The timing certainly fits.  Amazon got around the fact that major publishers have refused to buy into this new program by focusing on their KDP titles, smaller publishers, and by outright purchase of each rented eBook that they could get their hands on through wholesale arrangements.  This last move is what causes the ill will since many publishers and authors feel that this exceeds the scope of their current relationships with Amazon.

While nobody involved in the Prime lending library is directly losing money, a major worry in the industry is that eBooks will lose perceived value.  If customers start thinking of eBooks as somehow inherently cheaper that printed books, then printed Book sales will suffer and publishers would be forced to rely on sales of the eBooks, which means being subject to Amazon and Barnes & Noble even more than they are now.  This is the same sort of reasoning that brought on the behind-the-scenes deal with Apple to fix prices of eBooks around the time the iBooks store opened up.

I would say that this is going to go poorly for Penguin.  While their need to react is understandable given that they feel wronged, the targeting was off a bit.  Instead of attacking Amazon directly, they have gone after their own readers.  Yes, the Amazon deal with OverDrive increases the incentive to purchase a Kindle, but going after libraries doesn’t do a lot to make you look better to a customer base that loves to read.  The Kindle is unlikely to be pushed out of the #1 slot in eBook Readers any time soon, even if all the major publishers pulled out of the library system in the same way.  It’s difficult to understand what Penguin is still hoping to accomplish here.

2 thoughts on “Penguin, Overdrive, and Amazon: Kindle Library Lending Gets Complicated”

  1. “…a major worry in the industry is that eBooks will lose perceived value.”

    eBooks SHOULD have less value than physical books and most people instinctively know that. See all of the pricing comments in the Kindle forums. When a book doesn’t have physical printing or distribution costs, when there is no longer such a thing as ‘out of print’ to artificially create scarcity, and when purchasers can’t loan, sell, or give away their legal copy, the ebook has less value.

    I think publishers are under the impression that each of their books is a unique item that people will pay any price to read. That is not true. Most books can be easily substituted for other books, especially by people who are avid genre readers, one mystery or romance is as good as another. Therefore, small publishers and indie authors who get this are winning marketshare as the Big 6 publishers price their wares out of the market. Limiting ebook access at libraries just exacerbates the problem.

    Checking out Kindle ebooks from libraries is SO much easier than ePub books. No extra software or a computer required. Checkout from your library site via the browser on your Kindle (or phone, or computer) and click Get from Library at Amazon. As for security concerns regarding Amazon instead of Overdrive, I trust the security at Amazon far more than just about any other site. Plus, the easier you make it to get the book the less likely it is that people will look for illegal copies.

    Artificial barriers to purchase and borrowing are what hurts publishers, not Amazon or pirates. Books should be DRM-free and available worldwide with as few clicks as possible.

Leave a Reply

Comment moderation is enabled. Your comment may take some time to appear.